Will Erwin support Eren's resounding plans?

Important points

• Erwin's calculated brutality may support Eren's Rumbling plan as a strategic obstacle to Marley.
• Erwin's pragmatism and strategic thinking may lead to a more diplomatic solution than Eren's destruction.
• Irwin's legacy as a leader suggests he will be a good-natured supporter of Rumbling. using it as a deterrent It is not a destructive measure.

in attack on titanLeadership and morality are deeply intertwined issues. where the characters must make impossible choices in order to survive. From the discovery of Marley and the outside world The story tests the characters' determination by questioning how far they will go to protect humanity. Although the methods are different But leaders Eren and Erwin have conflicting ideals. They have one aspect in common: they sacrificed everything for an idea. Figuring out what drives these characters reveals the turning points of their personal and moral problems.

One of the most interesting “what ifs” attack on titan This must be the case: if Erwin Smith survives, whether he supports Eren's controversial Rumbling plan or not remains to be seen. His calculated brutality was an essential part of his many victories within its walls. The question is, does that pragmatism extend to disastrous movements like the Rumbling? It's anyone's guess, of course, as speculation will fuel our investigation into Irwin's character. his motivation And what kind of reaction might be expected regarding the threat posed by Marley?

Irwin's idealism and brutality

A dream brightened by his father's death.

His journey begins with the death of his father. This led to the theory that beyond the walls was a place where humanity existed. This view was rejected by both society and the government. It instilled a deep-seated belief in Erwin to know if this was true or not. Even if it means losing your life. Unlike most people within the walls. He knew that somewhere in this world there might be life far away. By defining his worldview to unlock secrets hidden from the public eye. The mysterious circumstances of his father's death reinforce his determination to defy the odds. And in the end it was to prove his father right.

He often finds himself in moral gray due to his drive to find the truth. He is known for his selflessness. And like Eren, Erwin weighs the greater good against his personal ambitions at every turn. In the case of Irwin any risk Whatever is worth taking is fair game. Even if putting his comrades in danger came at a price. Wild ambition and ethical overreach It brings Eren's thoughts similar to Marleyan's later threats.

Erwin and Eren's attitude

Knowing that sacrifice is necessary for success

Both Erwin and Eren display a level of determination that makes them unrelenting in their pursuit of their visions. For Irwin This involved getting answers that he believed were beyond the walls. While for Eren It is a matter of ensuring the safety and freedom of the Eldians at all costs. in promoting their own agenda Each person has committed morally complex acts that he or she can follow. which seems too harsh to others.

In many ways, Erwin's thoughts align with Eren's determination in the latter part of the series. Erwin had never done anything as violent as a massacre. But many of his plans included sacrifices that most people would consider unethical. Considering Erwin's serious nature, He probably sees Rumbling as the lesser of two evils. But how far he will allow it to go is anyone's guess.

Will Irwin support Rumbling?

A leader's calculations in the face of Total War.

Had Erwin lived to find out about Marley's involvement and Eldian oppression? He may adopt a more strategic solution to this new threat. His curiosity was finally quenched when he discovered Marley's existence. Perhaps Erwin's ambitions are more towards the safety of the Eldians without necessarily total destruction. Instead of the Rumbling, he has the opportunity to create diplomacy or other means, since he has good abilities in Observing situations in a way that is overlooked

However, at the same time Irwin was a realist. And he knew that the Marlyans had nurtured and passed on their hatred of the Eldians for generations, and as such, he might have agreed to the Rumbling as a deterrent to further attacks. But it's not Eren's proposed course of action to wipe out the majority of humanity, so Erwin may be presenting a balanced argument where everyone else uses Rumbling as leverage rather than actual planning.

Erwin's reaction to Eren's actions.

Direct or confront former comrades

Eren's actions in Rumbling, which were extreme measures based on his desire to protect Paradis, may have gained some sympathy from Erwin. Lee and others in the world, negotiate their position. On the other hand, as a strategist He would definitely go against Eren's plans. and thus would justify controlled use for purposes of balancing rather than genocide.

If Erwin is deeply opposed to Eren's methods. He might try to stop him by offering another solution. As we already know how hopeless Eren is when he tries to control Hanji. If you knew a better way Knowing the moral repercussions and the price. Total destruction could be brought to Paradis one way or another. He might negotiate with Eren. It offered a vision to protect the Eldians without destroying the entire world. Such advice might change Eren's plans. and may help reduce the intensity of conflict.

How can the results change?

Paradis and Eldia are choosing different paths.

If Erwin influences Eren, which is the course of events in attack on titan It would probably be different. Meanwhile, Eren decides to enter an all-out war. Erwin would probably lead the story in a negotiated way that would catch the attention of both Paradis and the outside world. Maybe with his strategic thinking Erwin was able to solve the problem at hand and save Eldia without causing chaos in the world. Therefore, it searches for a new path to peace.

Another example of this parallel universe is whether or not Paradis needed to co-exist in a state of tension where both Marley and the world were completely unscathed. with Erwin at the helm. Leading Paradis, there may be considerable preparation for the defenders to display limited power to prevent them from stagnating diplomatically to leave room for further alliances or understandings.

The potential impact of the plan is resounding.

Leaders who are torn between ideals and reality

Irwin's legacy as a strategic but idealistic leader Talk about how his approach differs from Eren's towards the Marlyan threat. Even though he has Eren's willingness to do whatever is necessary. But Erwin's strategic and knowledge-seeking nature might lead him to a completely harmless solution. If Erwin supports Eren It's likely an endorsement aimed at using Rumbling as a deterrent rather than an apocalyptic endgame.

The question of Erwin's hypothetical participation in Rumbling is complicated: How much of his belief in realistic would he be willing to accept Eren's plan? Or will his ideals push him towards a more balanced approach? Fans can only speculate. One thing remains clear: Erwin's appearance will likely leave an indelible mark on the plot of attack on titan And it can lead to a fate that is far from what it really is.