summarize
-
Dune: Messiah's adaptation poses challenges due to its lack of action. focus on politics and a dark and brooding storyline.
-
Dune: Episode Three May Fight Audience's Expectations for a Blockbuster Finale without high-octane performances
-
Villeneuve is faced with the task of conveying Paul's negative arc. Atreides in a politically sensitive atmosphere and risk conflict
The upcoming adjustment of Dun: Messiah It might be the most anticipated sci-fi project of the near future, however, director Denis Villeneuve faces significant obstacles that he must overcome to make his grand vision a reality. Maybe more than anything else Dun Movie or TV show
I didn't expect that I couldn't take pictures. Dun The novel must be divided into two parts. with many details abbreviated or omitted. So it's understandable why they had to adapt. Dune Messiah It might be equal or even more challenging. The sequel to Frank's original science fiction novel. Herbert brings a complexity of his own. It's not just their sheer size and sprawling length. But it also includes style and content that can be difficult to translate to the big screen.

related
Dune Messiah – Denis Villeneuve's potential third Dune movie explained
Dune: Part Two calls for a sequel And the director has the perfect follow-up, should Warner Bros. greenlight a sequel.
Why is it? Dune Messiah Difficult to adapt?
less action more politics
Dun: Messiah It's likely to create an outstanding trilogy that rivals classics like star wars– The Lord of the Ringsand many more, but problems in use Dune Messiah This is because the source material for the third film is that it may not align with the studio's vision of a contemporary trilogy. compared to part one Dune: Part Two Emphasis on action rather than dialogue. Therefore, it is natural for viewers to expect the climactic battle in the third film. But fans of the books know that's not the case.
What happened in Dune Messiah–
Dune Messiah It takes place 12 years after Paul Atreides became emperor. during his reign More than 60 billion people have died, but Paul continues to justify these actions through his vision. His power grew so uncontrollable that factions such as the Bene Gesserit and the Spacing Guild were forced to conspire to overthrow him.
Dune Messiah's lack of excitement
Problems for the final trilogy
The story of Dune Messiah It's a dark, brooding story. This is compared to the first book, which had a clearly defined villain and had dramatic moments like Paul riding a sandworm. This sequel is much less action-packed. Messiah Focus on palace intrigue Paul's inner conflict and descent from a totalitarian system There isn't much room for a cinematic set. Even the war is spoken of as a background event. with only the consequences being felt later.
This can be a challenge for viewers who expect to see high-octane shows after all. second part– instead of a blockbuster movie They will receive thoughtful stories about corruption, sacrifice and the dangers of totalitarian power. If you receive a warm response Dune: Prophecy Teach us everything A voice that proceeds slowly And this heavy dialogue didn't have the impact Warner Bros. was hoping for.
Paul Atreides' problematic arc is being shown.
A cautionary tale against hero worship.
Another major challenge that Villeneuve and his team of writers had to overcome was how to present Paul Atreides' negative arc in Dun: Messiah– Dune: Part Two It has been shown that the character of Timothy Chalamet began to let the power consume him. Dun It serves as a cautionary tale against the hero worship Frank Herbert intended to write. Dune Messiah To clear up misconceptions about Paul as a hero. He mentioned this in a 1980 article on Dune Genesis:
This is one of my themes for Dune: Don't hand over all your important abilities to the powerful. No matter how admirable those people are, Under the hero's facade You will find humans making human mistakes. Huge problems arise when human error becomes huge for superheroes.
Potential political correctness issues
This sequel needs to be fully committed to its portrayal of Paul. Atrides as a ruthless ruler who murdered billions and justifies his actions for a larger purpose. In fact, there is an important conversation with Stilgar in the book where Paul addresses the person. in real-life history such as Genghis Khan and Adolf Hitler to explain his reasons. Such a scene is unlikely to translate well with today's social, political, and cultural climate. Dune: Prophecy Conflict was avoided by not naming the Butlerian Jihad as it is called in the book. Instead, they called this event the Machine War.
It is unlikely that producers will confront the darker aspects of Paul's character. Atreides fully, on the other hand, toning it down or omitting it for public consumption would reduce his weight as an anti-hero. Modern audiences, though, accept moral protagonists. But Paul's journey from prophesied savior to genocidal ruler may be too intense for many to handle.
Dune: Messiah is still a masterpiece.
The reward is worth the risk.
Not every major movie has a big battle in the third act. However Dune Messiah Because it is a mostly political and religious story. There is still room for high stakes and threatening enemies. Moreover, The difficulty of justifying Paul's character development continues to prove how great it is. If only his arc had been perfectly portrayed. It might turn out to be a remarkable achievement in the film industry for deconstructing the hero archetype on this level.
The best way to achieve this is to depict real war. It shows some parts of the war. Rather than starting the story after the war has already taken place like in the book, Villeneuve has already done this in previous films, expanding on the elements of the war. Dun Where Herbert was swept away or relegated to the background, Peter Jackson did something similar. The Lord of the RingsHe took small details from the book and transformed them into grand scenes.
If anyone can pull it off, it's Denis Villeneuve. Blade Runner 2049 Directors can still choose to take their own creative liberties and incorporate new elements. of the Holy War to add color. Some people consider that Dune Messiah The novel will be the final chapter of DunWhile others saw it as a companion piece, however, it was up to Villeneuve to transform it into an iconic franchise finale that balanced action and philosophy.

Dune: Part Two
- Release date
-
February 27, 2024
- director
-
Denis Villeneuve
- Runtime
-
167 minutes